The World of Playing Cards Logo
Published December 20, 2013 Updated April 08, 2022

36: Minor Makers of the 19th Century

In 19th century England there were a number of makers who produced cards in relatively small quantities.

United Kingdom Brotherton Fuller Stopforth Wheeler Add to Collection

In 19th century England there were a number of makers who produced cards in relatively small quantities. There are also a number of instances where it is difficult to know how long a particular maker operated; this is partly because some makers had more important manufacturing outputs or business interests. For example, Creswick (see page 32) was a stationer and Turnbull made all kinds of board for artistic purposes (see the wopc main website). Also, some makers gave up making playing cards and went into another related business, e.g. pasteboard making. So, if a firm continued over a considerable period, it's not always clear when the card-making activity occurred. The dates, as far as I can determine them, can be found on the timeline on page 20. For a list of my wood-block cards by some of these makers click here

S & J FULLER

Active 1809-52, Garter AS issued August, 1808, Old Frizzle in 1828. Besides the non-standard Imperial Royal Cards (see wopc main website), they produced a few standard packs over the years. They were mostly of the normal Type I, though there is an unusually coloured one from the Old Frizzle period. The QS and QH are particularly noteworthy in having one eye of Type I and the other of Type II!

Above: Fuller, c.1830

Above: the more usual Type I, c.1830

Henry HART

An 18th century maker who disappears for a while and then comes back (presumably the same man), only to go bankrupt in 1799. The odd thing about Hart is that a lot of packs appear with his ASs, even in the United States, so maybe his surplus aces were distributed (or sold illegally after he finished trading) all over the place. Many of the Hart packs on the plainbacks website do not seem to be genuine. Here is a genuine one, though, from c.1768 (A25).

The ones discussed on page 39 from the plainbacks website, though, do not look like genuine Hart packs, even though the ASs look genuine.

STOPFORTH

1801 is the date of his first Garter AS; the firm became Stopforth & Son in 1824, and is listed as Ann Stopforth in 1838, after which date the firm disappears. Originally he was foreman to Gibson, and this is specified on some of his early Garter Aces. He used both types of court (I and II), though in the later Old Frizzle period he produced cards with Type III courts as well, like those of Reynolds.

Above: Type I, c.1810

Above: A later Type I pack with Old Frizzle, c.1828

Above: Type II, c.1805

Above: Type III, c.1835

He also produced a pack using Hunt's HB5 courts (see page 30) with his own AS. Whether he was the first to use these blocks I don't know.

Above: HB5, redrawn courts in small format

Stopforth and Son are also credited with engraving two packs for Charles Hodges, the Geographical Cards of c.1827 and the Astrophilogeon astronomical game of 1828. (See wopc website).

Josiah STONE

A rather obscure maker, who is not listed in the Post Office directories of the period. His first AS is listed in 1812 with a recut in 1820. His address is given as 10, Belle Sauvage Yard. He is still listed as a card-maker in 1825 in the Government report on taxation, but there is a reference to large numbers of his aces being returned or reassigned to Creswick, which suggests the business was on the wane.

Above: Stone

These courts, with their elongated features and large, Type II eyes, were taken over by Creswick and are sometimes used by Hall. In 1841 an E.J. Stone appears at the same Belle Sauvage address, but what relationship this firm might have had with the earlier one is impossible to say. Equally unclear as regards relatedness are the later firms listed under card-makers (with all the ambiguity that implies): Stone, Watson & Co. (1869-73) at 6-8 Fulwood's Rents, and Stone, Langdon & Stone (1875-6) at the same address. These are just a few of the unsolved mysteries of this period.

BROTHERTON and WHIT(T)AKER

They were partners, certainly from 1827 until 1840. Robert Whit(t)aker spelled his name variously with one or two ts. Their address was 13-15 Little Britain. Whereas a street still exists with this name along one side of St Bartholomew's Hospital, there is no sign of Victorian buildings anymore: they have been replaced by modern office blocks.

Brotherton's name appears on the Garter ASs, whereas Whitaker's appears on Old Frizzle, though he also used a lot of unappropriated aces. Brotherton's dates are given as 1789-1840 according to Maxted's book on The London book trades (1977). Although Whitaker's factory was burned down in 1851, the year he exhibited his cards at the Great Exhibition, he continued to produce cards until 1858. This date comes from a hand-written list of playing card production found in the De La Rue archives by Mike Goodall. There is no entry for the maker for 1859, and I have never seen a post-Frizzle AS with his name on it. However, from 1859-61 John Brotherton Whitaker is listed in the London Post Office directory at 13-14 Little Britain, and in 1862-63 Joseph Cooper Whitaker appears at 14 Little Britain. These must have been surviving family members right at the end of the production period. The original Robert Whitaker was born in 1786, making him 65 at the time of the 1851 census, in which he is listed as a card-maker. Another Robert Whitaker, probably his son, is listed in the same census as a card-maker workman, who was born in 1826. It is likely that he took over the business some time during the 1850s, but that is not mentioned anywhere.

The earliest Brotherton pack I've seen is in the Cuming Museum, London, and dates to c.1792. It has a wrapper with it, too. The courts are an early version of Type I with a black outline.

Above: c.1792, Cuming Museum

Later packs with a higher tax rate date from c.1805-10; they have the slightly later kind of Type I courts used by other makers, too. The outlines are blue.

Above: c.1805

There is also a pack on Paul Bostock's Plainbacks website with the later courts but an AS from 1789-1801, and a Whitaker pack with similar courts and Old Frizzle.

Whitaker redesigned his courts, probably around 1840, and many of them resemble those of Lawrence & Cohen and other US makers who went on to constitute the New York Consolidated Card Co., and who used them from c.1855 onwards. They are not like the courts of other English makers of the period.

Above: BW1, c.1840-55

There are different pip types, on the number cards as well. In addition to Old Frizzle and the usual Export AS, Whitaker also used the Isle of Man AS (see page 5 of this blog).

The other version of his single-ended courts is much more like the courts of Lawrence & Cohen and are also found in some Belgian packs. Whether they were made for Whitaker in Belgium after the 1851 fire is difficult to say. (For a set of Lawrence & Cohen courts, see page 13 of this blog.)

Above: BW2, 1850s

The pack he made for the Great Exhibition with a picture of the Crystal Palace on the backs has these courts. Unfortunately, the background colour is a dull blue with a steel-engraved image of the Palace in gold, so it doesn't show up well on a scan.





He also had packs with a decorative overlay on the courts and all the pips, often with export ASs.

Above: BW2 with fancy overlay, 1850s

His double-ended courts are from the same plates as those by Perry, but the colour distribution is different.

Above: Whitaker BW3, c.1855

Whether there was any connection between Whitaker and Perry I don't know. Perry, a stationer, had cards made for him with his own ASs from 1865-68.

Above: Perry, 1865-68

These cards were probably made by Steer. The pack illustrated below is from the Albert Field collection at the University of Columbia. It demonstrates that the courts are the same as those used by Perry about the same time (BW3), as described by Sylvia Mann in her catalogue of the William Penn collection. The AS is also the same except for Steer's name. Sorry that the image is not of the best quality.

Above: Steer, c.1865

Whitaker also seems to have made patience cards from quite an early date. I've only seen anonymous packs, with the AS as a garden spade, but the court design is a redrawing of BW1.

Above: BW4 patience, 1850s

After Whitaker disappeared, the only cards with BW2 courts are to be found in Belgian packs, but I am still unsure as to who printed them. Anton Benda imported some packs into England from c.1860-1880 with these courts and an AS based on the English Export AS of the Old Frizzle period.

If you compare this with the anonymous one illustrated on page 18 of the blog, this suggests Mesmaekers was the maker. Who knows?! See also page 37.

THE WHEELERS

There were three Wheelers who made cards, but it isn't clear what their relationship was. Thomas, the earliest name we have, was possibly the father (or older relative) of William and Henry. Thomas Wheeler appears in directories at 2 Richbell St (1799), 8 Middle Row, Holborn (1801), 118 Holborn Hill (1802-07) and 127 Holborn Hill (1807-21). His early cards are particularly crude, as illustrated below. They are a poor copy of the courts produced by Hall at the time.

Above: From the main wopc website

However, he soon changed to a more usual style of court like those of Brotherton. The cards of the top export pack are slightly reduced in size and have gold leaf on each edge. Many Wheeler aces turn up in what are most likely to be second-hand packs, because the courts don’t match the ace (for more details of mixed packs, see page 34). The lower example below has Hall courts.

He also seems to have used Type II courts different from the early ones above.

Above: from Sylvia Mann's collection

The distinctive AS was used in all his packs for the home market, although it would appear that it was originally designed for his Ludlow's Knights Cards of around 1800. These were an attempt to introduce some innovations such as double-ended pip cards and in a second version double-ended courts. The design of the courts is even cruder than usual and the double-ended ones are not even mirror images, nor are they based on the single-figure ones.

Above: from Plainbacks website

Above: from Plainbacks website

Ludlow aces of clubs were sometimes used as ASs illegally by stencilling a spade over the centre of the club design. They appear with cards by different makers, so were probably part of the second-hand trade.

William Wheeler was assigned a Garter AS in 1821 and is listed in directories at 11 King St., Snow Hill from 1822-28. A pack of his cards has recently been illustrated by Neil Darbyshire in the EPCS Newsletter.

Henry Wheeler, the maker who was transported in 1836 for illegally having Garter ASs in his possession, is listed at 4 Leather Lane in 1824, but in 1828 and 1829 he had moved to 93 Leather Lane; in 1830 he was at 22 Greville St, Hatton Garden; in 1832-34 he was at 25 Aldersgate; and in 1836, the year of his trial, he was at 122 St John St., Smithfield.

Above: a (legal) Henry Wheeler pack with Old Frizzle; the courts are Type III, like those of Reynolds.

A Henry Wheeler appears at 3 Back Church Lane in 1839 and he is listed as a pasteboard-maker (not cards) from 1844-55 at 14 Coppice Row and in 1859 and 1860 at 16 Vineyard Walk, Clerkenwell. Whether this person was the deported Henry's son I don't know, but he was born in 1817, so was clearly not the deported card-maker. In the 1871 census he is still listed as a card-maker (pasteboard) and his birth-place is given as Clerkenwell.

There is an interesting article about the Wheelers by Michael Cooper, first published in the IPCS Journal and recently reproduced in the EPCS Newsletter.

avatar
137 Articles

By Ken Lodge

Member since May 14, 2012

​I'm Ken Lodge and have been collecting playing cards since I was about eighteen months old (1945). I am also a trained academic, so I can observe and analyze reasonably well. I've applied these analytical techniques over a long period of time to the study of playing cards and have managed to assemble a large amount of information about them, especially those of the standard English pattern. About Ken Lodge →


Related Articles

Woodblock and Stencil Queen of Clubs

Woodblock and Stencil Queen of Clubs

A limited edition art print of the Queen of Clubs 1984 woodblock joker.

Woodblock and Stencil Jack of Clubs

Woodblock and Stencil Jack of Clubs

A limited edition art print of the Jack of Clubs 1984 woodblock joker.

Woodblock and Stencil Joker

Woodblock and Stencil Joker

A limited edition art print of the 1984 woodblock joker.

Woodblock and Stencil King of Diamonds

Woodblock and Stencil King of Diamonds

A limited edition art print of the King of Diamonds 1984 woodblock joker.

1904 Miniature Card Dominoes

Miniature Card Dominoes

A miniature set of Goodall domino cards (5.9 x 3.5 cms) still in perfect condition.

1875 T. Drayton & Son

T. Drayton & Son

Bezique and Whist boxed sets by T. Drayton & Son, London, c.1875.

2011 Colour doodle deck

Colour doodle deck

“1952-2002 commemorative deck” customised with doodles by an uncredited artist, UK, 2011.

2020 Alice in Wonderland: we’re all mad here

Alice in Wonderland: we’re all mad here

Alice in Wonderland themed playing cards, UK, 2020.

2023 Wren 300 playing cards

Wren 300 playing cards

Papercuts by Chloe Campbell of the 52 Wren churches in the City of London.

2023 Marlow playing cards

Marlow playing cards

Visitor attractions and businesses to be found in Marlow, Buckinghamshire.

2010 Playing Politics 2010

Playing Politics 2010

“Playing Politics ’10: With no expenses spared” featuring caricatures by Oliver Preston, published b...

1992 Playing Politics ’92: Pack of lies

Playing Politics ’92: Pack of lies

Playing Politics ’92: Pack of lies with caricatures by Grant Robertson, UK.

2005 B-Deck

B-Deck

“B-Deck” scurrilous playing cards poking fun at a former UK prime minister.

1967 Winstanley Geographical cards

Winstanley Geographical cards

Facsimile of Winstanley’s Geographical cards produced by Harold & Virginia Wayland, 1967.

1971 Meal Tub Plot

Meal Tub Plot

Meal Tub Plot playing cards [facsimile] with 17th century sketches by Francis Barlow.

Golf playing cards

Golf playing cards

Golf playing cards published by Marks & Spencer, UK.

2011 Great inventions playing cards

Great inventions playing cards

Great inventions playing cards designed by Gary Wyatt, United Kingdom, 2011.

1980 Christmas 1980 playing cards

Christmas 1980 playing cards

Festive courts on a Waddingtons pack designed to celebrate Christmas 1980.

Gone to Pot: Gardener’s playing cards

Gone to Pot: Gardener’s playing cards

‘Gone to Pot’: special playing cards for keen gardeners, United Kingdom.

2023 The Tarot Strikes Back

The Tarot Strikes Back

Roy Huteson Stewart's The Tarot Strikes Back combines Star Wars with Rider-Waite tarot imagery.

Tottering-by-Gently

Tottering-by-Gently

‘Tottering-by-Gently’ playing cards with cartoons by Annie Tempest.

1990 Sally Ferries Euro playing cards

Sally Ferries Euro playing cards

Sally Ferries Euro playing cards and phrase pack, United Kingdom.

Don’t come back

Don’t come back

“Don’t come back” playing cards produced by Hounslow NHS Primary Care Trust and Feltham Young Offend...

1998 From Empire to Commonwealth

From Empire to Commonwealth

Flags, locations and admission dates of 52 Commonwealth countries.

2023 House of Tudor

House of Tudor

Randy Butterfield's House of Tudor playing cards feature detailed art in a high-quality collectible ...

75: Early American cards

75: Early American cards

An overview of some of the early cards made in the United States.

2020 The Pack of Positivity

The Pack of Positivity

Katie Abey’s rainbow-coloured designs using crazy animals to convey motivating phrases.

2004 On-line offsite data backup

On-line offsite data backup

On-line offsite data backup publicity playing cards produced by The Bunker, United Kingdom, c. 2004....

2002 The Famous Dinosaurs Playing Cards

The Famous Dinosaurs Playing Cards

54 different dinosaurs, both large and small, illustrated by Cecilia Fitzsimons.

1980 Commemorative Olympic Playing Cards

Commemorative Olympic Playing Cards

Commemorative Olympic Playing Cards produced by Waddingtons exclusively for Stanley Gibbons Antiquar...

2015 Dorset Dialect Trails

Dorset Dialect Trails

‘Dorset Dialect Trails’ playing cards, United Kingdom, 2015.

1986 Clamcleats playing cards

Clamcleats playing cards

Clamcleats playing cards for sailors designed by Celia Allison, New Zealand, 1986.

2008 Around the world in 54 cards

Around the world in 54 cards

“Around the world in 54 cards” hand-coloured transformation pack produced by Peter Wood, United King...

2008 The Journey

The Journey

‘The Journey’ limited edition playing cards produced by Peter Wood, UK, 2008.

Pretty Frills

Pretty Frills

‘Pretty Frills’ playing cards promoting curtain and blind accessories.

1859 The Origin of Patience Games in English

The Origin of Patience Games in English

Jessel’s Bibliography of works in English on Playing Cards and Gaming describes “The first book on P...

2011 The Broons and Oor Wullie playing cards

The Broons and Oor Wullie playing cards

Characters from The Broons and Oor Wullie comic strips on their 75th anniversary.

2009 History of London illustrated playing cards

History of London illustrated playing cards

A catalogue in 54 cards of some of the treasures held within the Museum of London collections.

2006 Ladbroke Sporting Casino

Ladbroke Sporting Casino

Ladbroke Sporting Casino caricature cartoon playing cards, U.K, c.2006.

1869 The Evolution of Bezique boxed sets, 1869 to 1990

The Evolution of Bezique boxed sets, 1869 to 1990

The first company to register Bezique materials with Stationers’ Hall was Josh Reynolds & Son in Sep...

1915 Goodall 1915-1916 Sample Book

Goodall 1915-1916 Sample Book

Complete contents of a sample book by Goodall & Sons

1916 Goodall 1916 Rockleigh Sample Book

Goodall 1916 Rockleigh Sample Book

Complete contents of a sample book by Goodall

1879 Goodall 1879-1880 Sample Book

Goodall 1879-1880 Sample Book

Complete contents of a sample book by Goodall & Sons

1933 De La Rue 1932-1933 Sample Book of Advertising cards

De La Rue 1932-1933 Sample Book of Advertising cards

Complete contents of a sample book of advertising cards by De La Rue