On pages 28 and 29 I looked at number cards by De La Rue and James English, respectively, in order to help with dating and to show index variation. At first sight the number cards of standard English packs might not be the most exciting of topics to devote a whole page to. Compare this with those packs, some of which are standard regional patterns, which do have decorative number cards, for example the German regional patterns and tarot packs. And there are all the non-standard and transformation cards, too. Here's a selection.
Above: Piatnik Czech Heroes, 1944
Above: Prussian pattern
Above: the Jugendstil pack (reproduction)
Above: Casanova by Philibert
Above: Transformation "cartes à rire" by Louis Atthalin, 1814-15 (reproduction)
Above: modern transformation by Schick
[Thanks to Rex Pitts for most of the above illustrations.]
However, it's quite instructive to look at the history of number cards and to realize how little variation there is. First of all, it's quite remarkable to note that the basic arrangement of the pips on both English and French cards goes back several hundred years. The English pattern inherited the pip arrangement of the French regional patterns, so single-ended pip cards were the same for many different patterns. This arrangement was exported to wherever the French patterns were used. The one exception is to be found in the United States, where several makers had sevens with the central pip at the bottom rather than at the top of the card, though this could be inconsistent within one pack.
When double-ended pip cards were introduced in France and in England, there was a difference in how this was achieved. French pips change direction on the diagonal, whereas English pips have a horizontal division as follows: 2 = 1/1; 3 = 2/1; 4 = 2/2; 5 = 3/2 (these are the same in French packs). 6 = 4/2; 7 = 5/2; 8 = 5/3; 9 = 5/4; 10 = 5/5. Once again the American version is different for some makers with 7 = 4/3. American cards had double-ended number cards quite early, but they were often packed with single-ended courts. It was the other way round in England: double-ended courts are found with single-ended numbers into the 1880s.
French number cards from c.1870
It's sometimes possible to find English pattern cards with the French arrangement, if they have been made in France or some other European countries. It's also possible to find packs from America and elsewhere in which the sevens are variable between 4/3 and 5/2 for no apparent reason. I even have a De La Rue patience pack like this, whereas most examples of his are consistently 5/2.
Above: two sevens from a Dougherty pack of c.1860; a rare example from USPCC of c.1900, usually they were consistent with the English arrangement.
Interestingly, the one English firm that experimented with different ways of double-ending was Bancks Brothers. Late in the Old Frizzle period they had a small-format double-ended pack with turned courts (HB4) in which the number cards are divided diagonally, as in France.
Above: Bancks HB4, c.1860
A little later the firm tried a different method in which all the pips on one side of the card went one way. These are full-size packs with double-ended courts.
Above: Bancks HB1.1 with unusual orientation of double-ended pips, c.1870
Oddly, though, most of the later Bancks packs with double-ended courts had single-ended number cards, even those with HB6 printed by letterpress.
Clearly we are dealing here with an arbitrary tradition, but one which is fairly well adhered to. In cases where producers are not au fait with the tradition, all sorts of arrangements can occur. Makers recently established sometimes break with tradition: Richard Edward, in his early packs of c.1995-2000, arranged his pips in a very odd way, even using the traditional positions. Below, the arrangement on the seven is 5/2 but the gap between the two sets of suit signs is rather large; the eight is 4/4, not 5/3, and the nine is 5/4, but with the central pip at the top not in the middle.
Games & Print Services used the American arrangement on their sevens: 4/3 in their earliest packs.
The pip cards of the American reproductions of the Pierre Maréchal pack and the English single-figure pack (wrongly ascribed to a non-existent Bamford) using the illustrations from Gurney Benham's book are not in the least traditional; they illustrate a complete lack of observation.
And this brings me to Chinese Crackers. English playing cards are not traditional to the Far East, even though they've been accepted there in the course of interactions with Britain and the US. As we know, playing cards are now produced in their millions in China, Hong Kong and Taiwan, as well as Japan and India, but there is evidence that the tradition is still meaningless to those who actually design them. I'm still working on pages dealing with the court designs to be found produced in China and there are several oddities amongst them. But the number cards also come in for some rearrangement, which is quite difficult to explain as anything other than an arbitrary whim. Even though the vast majority of packs are just like their models, there are some unusual ones, such as those below. My favourite is the 10D that's actually the same as the 9D with a 10-index! And the 10S and 9S are also odd in that they are 3/2/2/3 and 2/2/3/2, respectively.
The odd arrangement on the 7H only: 2/1/2/2 can be found in a number of bridge packs and one court figure used for each suit is a common ploy for any maker who wants to cut costs. In the example below it's the heart courts being given extra duties.
The odd arrangement of nines noted above in Richard Edward packs can also be found, here with redrawn faces on the courts.
Below is a recent acquisition, which has a weird selection of courts: they are from three different court designs and even two of the kings have been turned. The eights and nines have the odd pip arrangement noted in other packs. Can you tell which courts come from which American originals?
Member since May 14, 2012
I'm Ken Lodge and have been collecting playing cards since I was about eighteen months old (1945). I am also a trained academic, so I can observe and analyze reasonably well. I've applied these analytical techniques over a long period of time to the study of playing cards and have managed to assemble a large amount of information about them, especially those of the standard English pattern. About Ken Lodge →
A limited edition art print of the King of Diamonds 1984 woodblock joker.
A limited edition art print of the Jack of Clubs 1984 woodblock joker.
Collectors pack of Antiques playing cards published by Collectors Cards, Abertillery, South Wales, c...
Fifty-five rare stamps of the world in full colour, published jointly by David Feldman SA of Switzer...
Luxury packs of cards have been produced since the 15th century, a trend that is very popular among ...
This deck was inherited from ancestors, it has has a family history surrounding it. Details of the l...
I suppose people collect for different reasons, rarity, quality, ingenuity of design, sentimental va...
Case Study: using detective work to identify and date a pack discovered in charity shop.
I collected playing cards when I was in primary school, by Jan Walls.
This is an archive list of my collection. I hope it will be of use and interest to others.
Chinese playing card makers have probably produced the widest variety of jokers of any single part o...
A brief look at the number cards used in standard English packs.
A brief survey of some of the current variation in the standard English pattern.
Interview with Tom and Judy Dawson from 52 Plus Joker. Chatting about the history of playing cards, ...
Dating is a particularly tricky but very interesting problem to tackle and there are many pitfalls. ...
A number of mixed packs appear for sale from time to time, but it's important to sort out what is me...
Notions like rarity and monetary value are slippery customers and need careful handling. And there...
There are some unusual designs in playing cards, even the shape of the card.
A fascinating collection that was the basis of a lot of research that we still benefit from today.
This is a personal account of some of my experiences collecting playing cards.
I'm Ken Lodge and have been collecting playing cards since I was about eighteen months old (1945). ...
The 'Joker' is believed to have been invented by American Euchre players who, when modifying the rul...