The World of Playing Cards Logo
Published May 29, 2010 Updated May 11, 2022

Andrew Dougherty 1848-1930

Andrew Dougherty was born in Donegal in Northern Ireland in 1827. He started his playing card business in New York in 1848.

USA Coughtry & Dougherty Dougherty Tally-Ho Triplicate

Andrew Dougherty’s story is a key part of the development of the American playing card industry and he can be credited with several innovations to playing cards.

Andrew Dougherty was born in Donegal in Northern Ireland in 1827. He started his playing card business in New York in 1848. It was also the same year Wisconsin was granted statehood and that saw the end of the Mexican-American War. Dougherty's story is a key part of the development of the American playing card industry as he can be credited with several innovations to playing cards. In 1849 he moved to a new address at Cliff Street, New York, and for a short time entered into partnership with two brothers named Coughtry. Coughtry & Dougherty stayed in business until c.1853. Dougherty soon prospered on his own, changing his address several times as he moved into better premises. Dougherty died in 1905 at the age of 78 and his sons continued to run the business in New York until 1907 when the United States Playing Card Company purchased it. USPCC kept the Dougherty business operating independently until 1930 when it was combined with the New York Consolidated Company to form Consolidated-Dougherty Card Co. Inc., a division of USPCC.

Coughtry & Dougherty

Dougherty's early cards are stencil-coloured and the suit signs are often askew. The court cards often have amusing expressions. The backs are sometimes plain, or sometimes a simple pattern. The historical context is that the New York Times started its presses and Isaac Singer invented the famous Singer Sewing Machine more or less at the same time.

Coughtry & Dougherty, c.1851

Above: cards produced during the Coughtry & Dougherty partnership era, c.1851. The colours appear to have been added by brush and stencil. An illuminated deck was also produced during this era, and which was subsequently published by A. Dougherty in c.1865 entitled 'Great Mogul Playing Cards'.

Andrew Dougherty

Andrew Dougherty, c.1850

Above: an early deck by Andrew Dougherty with the Cliff Street New York address on the Ace of Spades, square corners, c.1850   see more →

Dougherty had begun his card making enterprise at Brooklyn Street, then 148 Ann Stree, then at 78 Cliff Street, New York. About 1858 the Dougherty card-manufactory was moved to 26 Beekman Street. In 1864, Louis Pasteur invented what came to be known as the “pasteurization” process that he first applied to the treatment of wine, not milk. In that same year Dougherty produced his Excelsior cards. His ”Army & Navy” deck and his beautiful illuminated deck were issued in 1865, the same year that saw the laying of the transatlantic cable, the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln, the passage of the 13th amendment abolishing slavery and the publication of Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll. In 1872 Andrew Dougherty built a new factory at 76-80 Centre Street. The cards from the Centre Street factory are double-ended, but at first they seldom have indices. When they do, and when the corners are rounded instead of square, another innovation, both facts are mentioned on the wrapper.

A. Dougherty at the Centennial Exhibition, 1876

A. Dougherty at the Centennial Exhibition

Above: A. Dougherty's stall at the Centennial Exhibition, Philadelphia. The Centennial International Exhibition of 1876, the first official World's Fair to be held in the United States, was held in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, from May 10 to November 10, 1876, to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence in Philadelphia.


Andrew Dougherty, c.1878

Above: American Playing Cards, A. Dougherty, c.1878. One of the last no-indices decks issued by Dougherty, the ace being the basis for the subsequent Indicator series. Image courtesy Matt Probert.

The World of Playing Cards©

“The Best Bower” and “The Jolly Joker” cards

There is an old card game called Euchre which is still played to this day. It is played with a 32 card deck and at one time there were two additional cards which were extra trump cards. One was called a ‘Bower’ and the other, of even higher value, was called the ‘Best Bower’. Over time the game included only one ‘Bower’ card. Although the game was played with 32 cards, early American decks included a ‘Bower’ or ‘Best Bower’ card in their 52 card decks. This probably lead to the introduction of the Joker card.

“Triplicates” and “Indicators”

Dougherty first secured a patent for “Triplicates” in 1876, a novel type of indices with a miniature card in the top left-hand corner (and bottom right). These were the equivalent of NYCC's “Squeezers” and kept Dougherty at the forefront of innovation. There are several variations in the size and design of the “Triplicate” indices, with the smallest being the earliest. Dougherty's “Triplicate” playing cards have an intricately engraved Ace of Spades with a spread of cards inside the central Spade symbol proudly demonstrating the innovation.

Triplicate playing cards by Andrew Dougherty, c.1876 Triplicate playing cards by Andrew Dougherty, c.1878

Right: ‘Triplicate #18’ playing cards by Andrew Dougherty, c.1876. The earliest decks contain the ‘Best Bower’ but later editions contain different Jokers and a fancier Ace of Spades. This example has a decorative pictorial back design.

Lower Right: 'Triplicate No.18' playing cards by Andrew Dougherty, c.1878. This is the second version of the brand with a more elaborate Ace of Spades with the addition of two cherubs and an eagle at the top. Image courtesy Rod Starling.

Dougherty issued his final version of the triplicate brand in 1883. It introduced the beginnings of the corner numerical index and was the year that saw the opening of the famous Brooklyn Bridge, a masterpiece of engineering that still stands in full vigour today. The Manhattan end of the bridge landed just a few short blocks from Dougherty’s factory at 68 Centre Street. In 1883 Dougherty was granted a patent for “Indicator” cards with numbered indices, or “Indicators”, printed outside the border (just six years after NYCCC obtained its “Squeezer” patent for more or less the same thing). The earliest editions came with “Triplicates”, the miniature cards in the corners. These only ran for a year or less and were followed in 1894 by “Indicator No.50”.

Above: Dougherty's “Ivorette No.70” deck with patent dates on Ace of Spades, c.1883. It was the last of the Triplicate series and incorporated the first use of numbered indices. They only ran for a year or less and were followed in 1894 by “Indicator No.50”.   see more →

From the 1890s on Dougherty used either ‘Andrew Dougherty’ or ‘A. Dougherty’ on his Aces of Spades. As a general rule, the longer version was used on the earlier edition of each brand.

Spanish suited cards

It is recorded that Dougherty manufactured Spanish-suited cards, stencilled in golden yellow, as early as 1849 for sale in California, Texas, Mexico, South America and even in Europe, although most surviving examples of Spanish cards are from later dates. They are vivid reminders of those adventurous gold rush days of the middle of the century.

In the early 1900s Dougherty manufactured Austro-Hungarian cards in the 'Seasons' pattern. Examples of the Netherlands pattern are also known to have been manufactured by Dougherty.

detail from wrapper for Spanish suited cards, c.1882 Spanish suited cards, c.1882

Above: detail from wrapper for Spanish suited cards with his Centre Street address, c.1882. (Click images to see more)

Above: Hungarian No.32 playing cards produced c.1923 by A. Dougherty with German suit signs.

See also:Army & Navy”, c.1865 • ”Illuminated Playing Cards”, c.1865 • “Indicators No.50” • “Tally-Ho No.9” • ”Cruiser No.96”, c.1897.

“Tally-Ho”

The famous “Tally-Ho” brand was issued by Dougherty in 1885, the same year that the Bicycle 808 brand was introduced by U.S.P.C.C.

“Tally-Ho No.9” deck, c.1911

Above: cards from a c.1911 “Tally-Ho No.9” deck showing Dougherty's full name and street address. Dougherty sometimes included his first name on the Ace of Spades and sometimes only his initial. Also, sometimes he included his full street address on the Ace and sometimes only the State and Country. Earlier decks had the full name and address   more →

This brand is still available today. The earliest Ace of Spades had the Centre Street address and the Jolly Joker was used until the “Tally-Ho” Joker was introduced in the early 1900s. The brand has seen only minor variations over the years   read more →

“Marguerite #130”

Marguerite #130 Cherries back no.1307, c.1914

Above: Marguerite #130 playing cards with ‘Cherries’ named back no.1307, c.1914, in narrow size, gold edges, linoid finish. See more back designs

Marguerite #130 Nanette, c.1928

Above: Marguerite #130 playing cards with ‘Nanette’ named back. The date printed on the bridge rules card is 1926 and the date code on the ace of spades suggests 1928. Image courtesy Matt Probert.


Squeezers No.9352

Above: No.9352 Squeezers issued by Consolidated-Dougherty Card Co., Inc. c.1947 and imported into Argentina by Casa Bertrand Domec, Buenos Aires, whose details are overprinted on the ace of hearts. The “Tally-Ho” Joker is still being used.  read more...


REFERENCES

Dawson, Tom & Judy: The Hochman Encyclopedia of American Playing Cards, U.S. Games Systems Inc., 2000

Hargrave, Catherine Perry: A History of Playing Cards and a Bibliography of Cards and Gaming, Dover Publications, New York, 1966

Starling, Rod: Shuffling Along with History, in 'Clear the Decks', the Newsletter for 52 Plus Joker (edited by Judy Dawson), September 2010

Thanks to Rod Starling for generously sharing his knowledge and contributing images of cards from his collection.

Patent for “Triplicates”, 1876

avatar

By Simon Wintle

Member since February 01, 1996

View Articles

Curator and editor of the World of Playing Cards since 1996. He is a former committee member of the IPCS and was graphics editor of The Playing-Card journal for many years. He has lived at various times in Chile, England and Wales and is currently living in Extremadura, Spain. Simon's first limited edition pack of playing cards was a replica of a seventeenth century traditional English pack, which he produced from woodblocks and stencils.


Leave a Reply

Recommended

1987 Reagan’s Rogues Gallery

Reagan’s Rogues Gallery

A pack inspired by the Iran-Contra affair or Gipper-gate during the Reagan era, produced by R. Billingsley, USA, 1987.

1970 Grand Slam

Grand Slam

Limited edition gift set issued to mark the American Bicentennial, 1776-1976, produced by John Waddington Ltd and the Bristol Pottery for the British American Bicentenary Group, 1970.

2021 The Great Indoors

The Great Indoors

“The Great Indoors” playing cards published by DesignWorks Ink, Nashville, USA, 2021.

2018 Kings Wild Tigers Playing Cards

Kings Wild Tigers Playing Cards

Kings Wild Tigers is Jackson Robinson’s 27th successful playing card Kickstarter campaign. A luxury collectable deck inspired by vintage matchboxes.

2022 Billionaire Boys Club Playing Cards by Theory11

Billionaire Boys Club Playing Cards by Theory11

Limited edition luxury playing cards by Billionaire Boys Club and Theory 11.

1979 Gas Shortages

Gas Shortages

Screenprint designs on an ever-topical subject, designed and made by Sallie Chinkes, 1979.

1986 Helmsley Hotels

Helmsley Hotels

Publicity pack for the Harley and Helmsley Hotels, U.S.A., c.1986.

2014 Encarded First Edition by Paul Carpenter

Encarded First Edition by Paul Carpenter

The Encarded First Edition is a limited edition of 2,500 designed by Paul Carpenter and manufactured by the Expert Playing Card Company.

2005 Bush Cards – The Second Term

Bush Cards – The Second Term

Cards slanted to the right, issued to mark George W. Bush’s second term of office.

2019 National Playing Cards by Theory11

National Playing Cards by Theory11

Playing cards inspired by mysterious symbolism of secret societies as well as a tribute to the National Playing Card Co.

2012 Monarchs Playing Cards by Theory11

Monarchs Playing Cards by Theory11

Monarchs luxury playing cards by Theory11, featured in the film Now You See Me.

2015 Nomad Luxury Playing Cards

Nomad Luxury Playing Cards

Luxury playing cards produced by Theory11 in collaboration with The Nomad Hotel in New York City.

2003 Alcatraz: Rules and Regulations Playing Cards

Alcatraz: Rules and Regulations Playing Cards

Rules and regulations that guided prison life in America’s most notorious prison.

2021 Avengers Playing Cards by Theory11

Avengers Playing Cards by Theory11

Marvel’s Avengers: The Infinity Saga Premium Playing Cards produced by Theory11 and designed by Mattson Creative, 2021.

2014 A. Dougherty’s Triplicate Recreation

A. Dougherty’s Triplicate Recreation

A recreated of the original 1876, No. 18, Triplicate deck by A. Dougherty by Michael Scott in 2014.

2019 Triangle Playing Cards

Triangle Playing Cards

Triangle Playing Cards by Michael Scott.

1970 Notched Construction Cards

Notched Construction Cards

Two Notched Construction Card Sets by Shackman & Co, N.Y. 1970s.

2018 IBM Linux One

IBM Linux One

IBM Linux One playing cards, c.2018.

Spyscape

Spyscape

Spyscape espionage, surveillance and cryptography themed playing cards, 2018.

Lion Coffee

Lion Coffee

Lion Coffee Mother Goose card game, late 19th C.

1940 Fortune Telling

Fortune Telling

Fortune Telling cards by Whitman Publishing Co., 1940.

1953 Vargas Girls

Vargas Girls

‘Vargas Girls’ paintings by Alberto Vargas in a deck of cards published by Creative Playing Card Co Missouri.

1942 Anma US Armed Forces

Anma US Armed Forces

Anma US Armed Forces, 1942.

2011 Curator

Curator

The Curator Deck with designs by Emmanuel José with suit symbols cleverly transformed into artistic designs.

1989 Sherlock Holmes

Sherlock Holmes

Sherlock Holmes deck with caricatures by Jeff Decker published by Gemaco Playing Card Co. 1989

Warren Paper Products

Warren Paper Products

Warren Paper Products Co., Lafayette, Indiana, publishers of Built-Rite toys, games and puzzles.

1986 Christmas Playing Cards

Christmas Playing Cards

Christmas Playing Cards published by Novelty Playing Cards, Syracuse, New York, 1986.

1968 Hamm’s Beer

Hamm’s Beer

Hamm’s Beer promotion deck with bear cartoons by Frank M. Antoncich 1968.

Victory

Victory

“Victory" cards celebrating U.S. participation in the Allied victory, c.1945.

1976 Maya Deck

Maya Deck

The Maya Deck produced by Stancraft for Hoyle, 1976.

1840 Caleb Bartlett

Caleb Bartlett

Caleb Bartlett patriotic deck (reproduction), around 1835-40.

1951 Snap

Snap

Snap card game illustrated with animals, by Whitman Publishing Co., 1951.

1951 Roundup

Roundup

Roundup card game by Whitman Publishing, 1951.

1951 Old Maid

Old Maid

Old Maid card game by Whitman Publishing Co., 1951.

1951 Crazy Eights

Crazy Eights

Crazy Eights by Whitman Publishing Co., 1951.

1951 Animal Rummy

Animal Rummy

Animal Rummy by Whitman Publishing Co., 1951.

1951 Authors

Authors

Authors quartet game published by Whitman Publishing Co., 1951.

1951 Whitman 8 Game Box

Whitman 8 Game Box

Whitman 8 Card Games boxed set, 1951.

1974 Paddington

Paddington

Paddington card game published in UK by Whitman.

1880 Avilude or Game of Birds

Avilude or Game of Birds

Avilude or Game of Birds published by West & Lee, Worcester, Mass, c.1880.