The World of Playing Cards Logo

The English Playing Card Society

EPCS Logo

Promoting research into English card history since 1984. Members receive the EPCS magazine three times a year.

Join from £10/year

Paper Empires by Jason McKinstry

Published January 29, 2026 Updated January 29, 2026

A review of Jason McKinstry’s Paper Empires, Volume I, an illustrated study of early American playing-card makers and the firms behind them.

USACollectingLiteratureDoughertyHart (Samuel)Lawrence & CohenLewis I. CohenNew York Consolidated Card Co

Above: Paper Empires Vol I by Jason McKinstry.

Books on playing cards don’t come out that often, and really good, readable ones even less so. It is therefore a genuine pleasure to have this new book on the history of American Playing Cards – and the emphasis is as much on history as it is on cards. The author of Paper Empires, Jason McKinstry, will be known to many as a 52 Plus Joker member and as a frequent contributor to Card Culture.

The new book is highly visual so those who want just to look at the pictures will have plenty to keep them occupied and they will not be disappointed. These illustrations include maps, portraits of the people involved, contemporary illustrations, advertisements promotions and price lists, houses and factories, news cuttings, share certificates, burial grounds and of course a lot of representative cards.

Jason has also had a simple but brilliant idea that I have never seen before: many of the illustrations have has to be shrunk to fit in with the text and at the end of the book a good selection of these are reproduced again at a much large size.

In order to appreciate the nature of the era Jason is covering here, those unfamiliar with the history might try reading my article ‘American Cards 1800-1900 in one page’ on page 15. Jason’s Volume I begins after the pioneer period at exactly the point where industrialization is about to begin. We learn all about the rapid growth period up to the arrival of USPCC.

Right: Manhattan 1873 by G Degen from Paper Empires

By far the most successful of the 19th Century firms are referred to as the ‘Big Seven’: that's the first of L I Cohen, Samuel Hart, Andrew Dougherty, John A Levy, Lawrence & Cohen, New York Consoloidated Card Co. (NYCC). In fact we could think of these as a ‘Big Three’, i.e. NYCC and its constituent parts, Doughert and USPCC. NYCC's L I Cohen was the entrepreneurial inventor of a four-colour printing machine that changed playing card making for good. He and his family ruled the industry for around fifty years with only Dougherty as serious competition.

Paper Empires tells this story in full detail and by the end of each chapter – one per maker (L I Cohen, Andrew Dougherty, Samuel Hart and John J Levy here) you feel you know the person. Jason’s infor mation on Dougherty is particularly extensive. In each case one feels the presence of the real per son behind ‘the name on the box’, which is a real achievement by Jason.

There is a choice of format – paperback or digital (in the various formats used.). See Jason’s website. Perhaps the best thing is the ‘Vol I’ in the title: I am looking forward to Vol II, previewed in the first volume.

avatar
19 Articles

By Paul Bostock

United Kingdom • Member since May 07, 2024

Paul has been a collector of playing cards since his early teenage years, the mid 1970s. In the last 20 years or so he has specialised in standard English cards and their story. His collection, including many other English Standards, are featured on his website plainbacks.com. Paul is currently editor of Clear the Decks, the Journal of 52 Plus Joker, the American club for playing card collectors, and is a member of the IPCS Council, an EPCS member and a Past Master of the Worshipful Company of Makers of Playing cards, a City of London livery company.

Activity for Paper Empires by Jason McKinstry

Sign in to comment or save this article.


Related Articles

2026 Library Display

Library Display

Three seconds to spark a love of playing cards: one collector's library display challenge.

Playing Card Books - References

Playing Card Books - References

A guide to reference books for playing-card collectors, focusing on museum catalogues, collection su...

Advice and General Knowledge for Newer Collectors

Advice and General Knowledge for Newer Collectors

A little general knowledge goes a long way for newer collectors, helping you choose a focus and unde...

Illustrated Playing Cards

Illustrated Playing Cards

Illustrated (or “pictorial”) playing cards replace the standard faces with scenes and text, turning ...

Playing Card Books - Introductions to Collecting

Playing Card Books - Introductions to Collecting

A guide to introductory books for playing-card collectors, with reviews of Sylvia Mann, Rod Starling...

2019 Royal Mischief Transformation

Royal Mischief Transformation

Royal Mischief Transformation reworks Patrick Valenza’s Royal Mischief characters and imagery...

Classification of Numeral Card Designs in French-suited packs

Classification of Numeral Card Designs in French-suited packs

The classification of numeral cards in French-suited packs, covering various pip designs in over 400...

Are Playing Cards a Good Investment?

Are Playing Cards a Good Investment?

Playing cards can appreciate modestly, with historical annual gains of 2-3%. Rare cards offer higher...

Why our playing-cards look the way they do

Why our playing-cards look the way they do

Analysis of early playing card designs: origins, suit differences, standardization, technological ad...

Introduction to Collecting Themes

Introduction to Collecting Themes

Playing cards can be broadly categorised into standard and non-standard designs, with collectors app...

1875 Union Playing Card Co.

Union Playing Card Co.

Not much is known about this early manufacturer who is reckoned to have traded between c.1860s-1890s...

1920 Lighthouse No.922

Lighthouse No.922

“Lighthouse No.922” playing cards were introduced in c.1920.

1850 Andrew Dougherty c.1850

Andrew Dougherty c.1850

The idiosyncratic courts used in this deck were used by several other U.S. manufacturers, including ...

13: Some North American Cards

13: Some North American Cards

I deal with some of the US makers in more detail on other pages, but here is a brief introduction.

Lawrence & Cohen

Lawrence & Cohen

Lawrence & Cohen were successors to Lawrence, Cohen & Co.

1832 Lewis I. Cohen

Lewis I. Cohen

Lewis I. Cohen made his first deck of cards in 1832. In 1835 Mr Cohen invented a new machine to prin...

1871 New York Consolidated Card Company

New York Consolidated Card Company

The New York Consolidated Card Company was formed in 1871 by the merging of Lawrence & Cohen, Samuel...

1845 Samuel Hart, 1846-1871

Samuel Hart, 1846-1871

Samuel Hart was a prolific manufacturer of playing cards who commenced business sometime around 1845...

1863 The Joker Card

The Joker Card

The 'Joker' is believed to have been invented by American Euchre players who, when modifying the rul...


Sign in with Google